15/11/26

Renegotiating commercial contracts: how can contractual balance be preserved in the face of economic uncertainty?

Rising production costs, supply-chain disruptions, geopolitical tensions and increases in raw-material prices: businesses operate in an economic environment in which the conditions for performing contracts can change rapidly. In the face of such uncertainty, contractual renegotiation is a strategic risk-management tool. However, its legal requirements and limits must be understood.

‍

Introduction

The stability of commercial relationships traditionally rests on a fundamental principle: a validly concluded contract is binding on the parties. As a rule, each party must therefore honour the commitments it has undertaken, even where performance has become less economically advantageous.

In a context marked by market volatility, supply pressures and rapidly changing costs, however, strict adherence to the conditions originally negotiated may undermine the profitability of a transaction or even seriously jeopardise a commercial relationship over the longer term.

For businesses, the question is therefore no longer merely how to perform a contract, but also in what circumstances and by what means its terms may be adjusted.

Under Belgian law, this issue has taken on particular significance since Book 5 of the Belgian Civil Code entered into force on 1 January 2023. In particular, Article 5.74 provides for a mechanism allowing a party to request renegotiation of a contract where a change in circumstances meets certain conditions.

Can contractual renegotiation therefore serve as an effective means of protecting businesses’ commercial interests, and what legal mechanisms can help ensure that it is implemented securely?

1. The principle: the binding force of the contract remains the rule

1.1. A commitment that cannot be amended unilaterally

Article 5.69 of the Belgian Civil Code enshrines the principle that a contract lawfully entered into is binding on the parties as law.

This means that economic difficulties arising after a contract has been concluded do not, in themselves, release a party from its agreed obligations. An increase in raw-material prices, a reduction in margins or a fall in demand therefore does not automatically justify changing the contractual terms.

Article 5.70 of the Civil Code further provides that a contract may be amended or terminated only by mutual consent or on grounds authorised by law. Unless an applicable contractual or legal mechanism provides otherwise, a business cannot unilaterally impose a price increase, an extension of a deadline or a reduction in services on its contractual partner.

This rule has important commercial implications. A business that refuses to perform its obligations on the agreed terms solely because they have become less profitable may face a claim for performance or other remedies arising from contractual non-performance.

‍

1.2. Good faith as the framework for contractual performance

Article 5.73 of the Civil Code requires contracts to be performed in good faith and prohibits the abuse of rights.

This principle governs the parties’ conduct when performing their commitments. It does not, however, mean that a business is always required to accept a renegotiation request made by its contractual partner.

In practice, good faith calls for consideration of the specific circumstances of the commercial relationship, the applicable contractual provisions and the conduct of the parties. On its own, it does not create a general right to obtain an amendment to a contract.

A distinction must therefore be drawn between renegotiation freely agreed to by the parties and renegotiation that may be requested under a specific statutory mechanism.

‍

2. A change in circumstances: a statutory renegotiation mechanism

‍

2.1. The recognition of hardship under Belgian law

Article 5.74 of the Civil Code introduces a mechanism allowing a party to request renegotiation of a contract where new circumstances make its performance excessively onerous.

The provision nevertheless preserves a key principle: each party must perform its obligations even if they have become more costly or the value of the counter-performance has decreased.

The possibility of requesting renegotiation is therefore a carefully regulated exception, not a general right to revise any contract that has become economically disadvantageous.

Five cumulative conditions must be met for this mechanism to be invoked:

  • Performance has become excessively onerous: the change must make performance so burdensome that it cannot reasonably be required. A mere reduction in profitability will not necessarily be sufficient.
  • The change was unforeseeable: the new circumstances could not reasonably have been anticipated when the contract was concluded.
  • The change is not attributable to the debtor: within the meaning of Article 5.225 of the Civil Code, the change must not be attributable to the party requesting renegotiation.
  • The risk has not been assumed: the requesting party must not have assumed the risk in question.
  • The possibility has not been excluded by law or contract: neither the law nor the contract may exclude this option.

These conditions require a case-by-case assessment. The occurrence of an economic crisis, an international conflict or a supply-chain disruption is therefore not, in itself, sufficient to justify a request under Article 5.74.

‍

2.2. What does this mean for commercial contracts?

Consider a business that has undertaken to supply industrial components at a contractually fixed price over a period of several years.

Following an unforeseeable event, the cost of an essential raw material rises sharply. The business finds that performing the contract has become particularly onerous from an economic perspective.

In this situation, it could consider requesting renegotiation under Article 5.74, provided it can demonstrate that the statutory conditions are met and that it did not assume the risk concerned.

Conversely, if the contract expressly provides that the supplier bears fluctuations in the price of that raw material, or if the change could reasonably have been foreseen when the contract was concluded, the ability to rely on this statutory mechanism may be compromised.

The analysis must therefore go beyond measuring the increase in costs. It must also consider the contractual allocation of risks, the foreseeability of the change and its concrete impact on performance.

‍

3. Renegotiation: a process that requires a legal framework

3.1. A request to renegotiate does not suspend contractual obligations

One of the key features of Article 5.74 is that contractual obligations remain in force while negotiations are ongoing.

In other words, even where a party believes that it meets the statutory conditions for requesting an adjustment to the contract, it cannot assume that its obligations are automatically suspended.

A business that stops delivering, refuses to pay or unilaterally changes its prices solely because it has submitted a renegotiation request may therefore face legal risks.

It is advisable to formalise the request in writing, setting out in particular:

  • the new circumstances relied upon and why they were unforeseeable;
  • the concrete consequences of those circumstances for performance of the contract;
  • the financial evidence supporting the claim that performance has become excessively onerous;
  • the relevant contractual provisions, particularly those concerning indexation, force majeure and the allocation of risks;
  • the proposed adjustments and why they would help preserve the balance of the commercial relationship.

This approach helps clarify the difficulties encountered and creates a record of the exchanges between the parties.

‍

3.2. What adjustments can be considered?

Renegotiation does not necessarily have to result in a price increase or the termination of the commercial relationship. Depending on the nature of the contract and the parties’ interests, several solutions may be considered, for example:

  • A price adjustment: The parties may agree to revise the price, potentially on a temporary basis or by reference to specifically identified costs.
  • Revised deadlines: Postponing certain deadlines or changing the delivery schedule may help address a temporary supply difficulty.
  • A different allocation of risks: The parties may agree to share certain cost increases, introduce caps on increases or set thresholds that trigger a review
  • Changes to performance arrangements: The use of alternative raw materials, the replacement of a supplier or an adjustment to order volumes may also be considered, subject to applicable technical and regulatory constraints.
  • A negotiated exit: Where continuing the contract is no longer economically viable, the parties may seek an amicable termination and agree on its financial and operational consequences.

The aim is to identify a solution that is economically sustainable for both parties, rather than transferring the entire cost of the unforeseen event to one of them.

‍

4. Anticipating difficulties when drafting the contract

‍

Renegotiation should not be considered only once economic difficulties have materialised. The initial drafting of the contract is the first tool for preventing disputes.

4.1. Include a price-review clause

In long-term contracts or contracts involving successive performance, a price-review clause can allow the price to be adjusted automatically or periodically in line with changes in certain parameters.

The clause should specify the relevant indices or costs, the frequency of review, the calculation method and, where appropriate, any applicable caps or floors.

Imprecise drafting may, however, give rise to interpretation issues. It is therefore essential to define the chosen parameters objectively and to specify how changes in those parameters must be evidenced.

‍

4.2. Include a hardship clause

A hardship clause provides for renegotiation where new circumstances fundamentally alter the economic balance of the contract without necessarily making performance impossible.

It may specify, in particular:

  • the events that may trigger renegotiation;
  • the required threshold for cost variation or economic imbalance;
  • the information that the requesting party must provide;
  • the time limits for negotiations;
  • any interim measures that may be considered while discussions are ongoing;
  • the consequences of unsuccessful negotiations, such as mediation, referral to an independent expert or another dispute-resolution mechanism.

Such a clause makes it possible to tailor the mechanism to the characteristics of the relevant business activity. It should not, however, be confused with a force majeure clause: hardship primarily concerns excessive economic difficulty, whereas force majeure concerns the impossibility of performing an obligation under the applicable law or contract.

‍

4.3. Review force majeure and termination clauses

A well-drafted force majeure clause can specify the events covered, notification obligations, mitigation measures and the consequences of a temporary or permanent impediment.

However, not every cost increase or supply difficulty should be treated as force majeure. Under Belgian law, Article 5.226 of the Civil Code is based, in particular, on an impediment to performance that is not attributable to the debtor, taking into account whether the obstacle was unforeseeable and unavoidable.

Termination clauses also deserve particular attention. They should be coordinated with notice requirements, any applicable cure periods and the financial consequences of early termination.

Finally, businesses operating internationally should check which law governs the contract. The solutions available under Belgian law cannot automatically be applied to every contract governed by foreign law.

‍

Conclusion

Renegotiating commercial contracts is an important risk-management tool for businesses facing unforeseen economic changes. It can help preserve lasting commercial relationships, limit losses and avoid contractual breakdowns that would be detrimental to both parties.

Under Belgian law, Article 5.74 of the Civil Code provides, subject to strict conditions, an opportunity to request renegotiation where unforeseeable circumstances make performance excessively onerous. This mechanism does not, however, displace the binding force of the contract or authorise a party to suspend its commitments unilaterally.

For businesses, the best protection therefore remains a forward-looking approach: identifying risks during the initial negotiations, providing for appropriate review mechanisms and carefully documenting any difficulties that arise during performance.

In contractual matters, anticipating unforeseen events does not mean predicting every crisis; it means establishing a legal framework for dealing with them.

Vanbelle Law Boutique advises and supports businesses in the negotiation, review and renegotiation of commercial contracts, helping them protect their interests and navigate contractual challenges arising from changing economic circumstances.
REach out

Since you are unique, you deserve a personal and tailor-made approach

Let's work together
Contact